Airtable for systematic review?


#1

I’m trying to see if Airtable can be used for a systematic literature review and I was wondering if someone had any advice on this. What I am trying to do is extract certain data from ~300 scientific articles. 2 people from my team need to review each paper and then a third person has to compare the extracted data to make sure it matches. Does anyone have any templates that could help with this? I’m making a form to submit for each paper to make the data extraction easier, but I’m unsure how to account for the fact that each paper needs to be reviewed twice.


#2

Would you not create a new record for each person who reviews the paper and the use the Group function to compare the two reviews for the same paper?

Paper 1 reviewed by Person A…
Paper 1 reviewed by Person B…

Paper 2 reviewed by Person A…
Paper 2 reviewed by Person B…

Or are you trying to have one record for each paper with both reviewers notes on it?

Paper 1, Person A Notes, Person B Notes

You could create a form for each reviewer that was setup for the fields that their data will be entered into.