Hi @Dirk_Jan_de_Wit - the problem lies in the first part of the IF()
formula:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months') > 1
I created a formula field showing the output of this formula, i.e. of this:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months')
And the results are this:

The formula is outputting full months only, so right now it is the 17/05 for me so the formula for 17/03 shows “2”, i.e. 2 full months. For the 18/03, it isn’t yet 2 full months, just 1 and most of the 2nd, so only shows the result 1.
So, going back to the first part of the IF:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months') > 1
for 18/03 this won’t be satisfied and the last part of the IF formula will apply, i.e. just adding a single month.
What I think you need to do is make the formula:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months') >= 1
which will then give you this:

Is that what you are expecting to see?
JB
Hi @Dirk_Jan_de_Wit - the problem lies in the first part of the IF()
formula:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months') > 1
I created a formula field showing the output of this formula, i.e. of this:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months')
And the results are this:

The formula is outputting full months only, so right now it is the 17/05 for me so the formula for 17/03 shows “2”, i.e. 2 full months. For the 18/03, it isn’t yet 2 full months, just 1 and most of the 2nd, so only shows the result 1.
So, going back to the first part of the IF:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months') > 1
for 18/03 this won’t be satisfied and the last part of the IF formula will apply, i.e. just adding a single month.
What I think you need to do is make the formula:
DATETIME_DIFF(TODAY(),{Member since}, 'months') >= 1
which will then give you this:

Is that what you are expecting to see?
JB
That’s great! Thanks @JonathanBowen